For heavily stained water, the priority is contrast, vibration, and easy-to-find profiles. Bull Shad 2Knocker is the strongest match here because it’s a larger hard swimbait with a pronounced knocking sound, which helps bass locate it when visibility is poor. The two Bent Rod Fishing color options, PB&J - Soft Plastic Color and Watermelon Red - Custom Bait Color, are useful when you want a soft-plastic presentation with added visibility and flash from custom color patterns.
Switch to a louder or more high-vibration bait if bass aren’t finding a subtle soft plastic. If the water is only lightly stained, you can downsize and use more natural colors. If visibility is extremely poor, a bait with more thump, rattle, or a bigger profile usually outperforms finesse options.