For pressured winter walleye, the best starting point is usually a subtle soft-plastic minnow/shad. Lunker City 3.5" Fat Fin-S Fish is a strong finesse option with a subtle tail kick, and Lunker City 5" Fin-S Shad gives a more baitfish-like profile for open-water or slightly more aggressive fish.
If you want a reaction bait, Pro King Spoons Pro Spoon Clicker adds chatter and noise, which can help call fish in when they’re suspended or not actively tracking.
Pro King Spoons Walleye Spoons are a solid flash-and-flutter option for walleyes that want a more classic spoon presentation.
If you specifically want a true topwater jerkbait, there isn’t a strong topwater match in this set; these cards are better for subsurface winter walleye.