
For a saltwater shrimp fly, these are the strongest matches in the set. Big Y Fly Co Shrimp Gurgler - Fulling Mill is the best topwater option when fish are feeding shallow and reacting to surface disturbance. Big Y Fly Co Vlahos Bahama Shrimp - Fulling Mill is a good subtle subsurface shrimp for skinny flats and natural presentations. Big Y Fly Co Bonefish Bitters - RIO is the most clearly bonefish-focused bottom shrimp imitation. The Fly Crate Banded Shrimp and The Fly Crate Mantis Shrimp are lightweight flats shrimp patterns suited to tailing or skittish fish.
Switch to a deeper or more weighted pattern if fish are not showing on top or are feeding below the surface. If the water is very clear and fish are spooky, favor the more subtle shrimp like Vlahos Bahama Shrimp or Bonefish Bitters over the gurgler. If you need a deeper presentation than these flats shrimp, a different sinking fly or nymph-style pattern would be better.
Affiliate disclosure: Some product links are affiliate links. Tackle.net earns from qualifying purchases.