
For ice soft baits, the best starting point is usually small panfish plastics with subtle action. Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50 Count Bag-Blue Ice is a strong crappie-style option, while Pro Tour Baits NEW Custom ICE & Panfish Cricket and Pro Tour Baits NEW Custom ICE & Panfish 1 1/2" Grub (Waxie) are built for panfish and vertical ice presentations. If you want a little more body and glide, Custom Jigs & Spins Ice Fishing Jigs & Baits Authentx 4 Ringworm.html is a good ice-soft-bait profile. For a more complete ice-plastic setup, Custom Jigs & Spins Ice Fishing Jigs & Baits Glow Rotating Power Minnow Kit.html gives you a kit-style option.
Switch to larger or more aggressive soft baits if fish are suspended and chasing, or if you’re targeting bigger predators rather than panfish. If bites are light, downsize to the smallest cricket- or grub-style bait and slow the cadence. If you need more durability or a louder profile, move away from subtle panfish plastics and toward a bait with more action.
Affiliate disclosure: Some product links are affiliate links. Tackle.net earns from qualifying purchases.