
If you’re looking for ice soft baits, these are the strongest matches for panfish-style ice fishing plastics. The Original Finesse Plastic is a simple, low-profile option when fish want a subtle look. The Authentx 3.25 Paddletail and Authentx 4 Ringworm give you more body and movement for active fish. The Custom ICE & Panfish 1 1/2" Grub (Waxie) and Custom ICE & Panfish Cricket are especially good for panfish, with the cricket offering extra action for vertical jigging or under a bobber.
Switch to a different presentation if fish are suspended high, chasing bait, or ignoring plastics. In that case, a jigging spoon, live bait, or a more aggressive glow-style option may outproduce soft baits. If bites are very light, go smaller and more subtle; if fish are active, move up to paddletails or ringworms.
Affiliate disclosure: Some product links are affiliate links. Tackle.net earns from qualifying purchases.