You asked for blue flake / blue tail / black recoil baits, and these are the closest matches in the set. The two Blue Flake Blue Tail and 5.25" Blue Flake Blue Tail options match the blue-tail look directly, while the black-bodied chartreuse-tail versions give you the darker body contrast you mentioned with a similar recoil-bait profile.
For bass, the 5.25" versions are the stronger choice when you want a bigger casting bait and a more visible profile. The 3.25" versions are better when fish are pressured, keyed on smaller forage, or you want a finesse-style presentation.
Switch to a different lure if fish are chasing baitfish higher in the water column or want a more natural swim. In that case, Lawless Lures Tail Trio is a better subsurface swimming option. If bass are ignoring a soft-plastic profile, downsize to the 3.25" bait or move to a slower presentation around cover.