
If you mean 3–5 ft fishing depth, the best fit here is a short leader option plus mayfly patterns that cover the surface to just-below-surface zone. The Maine Fly Company Airflo- Polyleader / 5' Trout helps turn over dries, nymphs, and streamers and is a practical choice when you want a compact setup.
For trout on mayfly water, Barbless Flies Artisan Mohican Mayfly is a strong dry-fly option, while Barbless Flies Artisan Mayfly Loop-Winged Dun and Barbless Flies Artisan Mayfly CdC Emerger cover the emerger stage. Barbless Flies Brown Mayfly Nymph is the best pick if fish are feeding a little deeper in the 3–5 ft zone.
Switch to a deeper nymphing setup if fish are holding below 5 ft or not showing on top. Switch to a streamer or crankbait-style presentation if you’re targeting non-fly species or need a more aggressive reaction bite. If you meant 3–5 ft lure depth for bass, the squarebill crankbaits in this set are better than the fly items.
Affiliate disclosure: Some product links are affiliate links. Tackle.net earns from qualifying purchases.