Topwater Rats Are Crushing It Right NowShop SAC Pig
All comparisons
AI Lure Comparison

Pizz Swimbaits "Rat" vs FREEK FILES - SUBJECT:13 - Zombie Lab Rat Wake Bait

"Which fishing lure is better?"

AI Verdict

When comparing the Pizz Swimbaits "Rat" and the FREEK FILES - SUBJECT:13 - Zombie Lab Rat Wake Bait, it's essential to consider several factors, such as price, design, usability in different conditions, and target fish species. Let's break down the specifics of each lure.

Product Overview

1. Pizz Swimbaits "Rat"

  • Type: Topwater bait
  • Price: $200
  • Weight: 3.5 oz
  • Length: 5.5 in
  • Sink Rate: Floating
  • Best Season: Summer
  • Experience Level: Expert
  • Colors: Gray, Brown, Red, Yellow, Green
  • Pros: Realistic rat imitation, effective topwater action, durable construction
  • Cons: High price point, requires specific conditions for best use
  • Usage: Best used during the summer in the early morning or late evening when fish are active near the surface.

2. FREEK FILES - SUBJECT:13 - Zombie Lab Rat Wake Bait

  • Type: Topwater bait
  • Price: $249
  • Weight: N/A
  • Length: N/A
  • Sink Rate: Floating
  • Best Season: Year-round
  • Experience Level: Expert
  • Colors: Pink, White, Red
  • Pros: Unique design, effective surface disturbance
  • Cons: High price point
  • Usage: Ideal for calm waters during early morning or late evening with a steady retrieve to create a wake.

Detailed Comparison

Price and Value:

  • The Pizz Swimbaits lure is priced at $200, which is slightly lower than the FREEK FILES at $249. Given that both are premium products, the Pizz lure may offer better value, especially if you are focused on summer fishing.

Design and Aesthetics:

  • The Pizz Swimbaits offer a realistic rat imitation, which can be particularly effective in waters where bass and other predatory fish are accustomed to preying on rodents. The various color options also increase versatility.
  • The FREEK FILES lure features a unique and creative design with an imaginative backstory, which may appeal to some anglers looking for novelty and a conversation starter.

Weight and Length:

  • The Pizz Swimbaits has specific dimensions (3.5 oz and 5.5 in) that can be beneficial for casting accuracy and distance, especially in summer conditions. The weight is manageable for expert anglers, allowing for precise control.
  • The FREEK FILES does not provide specific weight or length details, making it hard to assess its casting and retrieval characteristics.

Usability in Different Conditions:

  • The Pizz Swimbaits is best suited for summer fishing, which is when the fish are most active and can be drawn to topwater lures.
  • Conversely, the FREEK FILES claims to be effective year-round, which could make it a more versatile option if you fish in various conditions and seasons.

Target Audience:

  • Both products are targeted towards expert anglers, but the Pizz Swimbaits may be more specialized for those focused on summer topwater fishing, while the FREEK FILES may attract those interested in unique designs and year-round application.

Conclusion

Recommendation:

  • If you primarily fish in the summer for species like bass and are looking for a lure that effectively mimics prey in those conditions, the Pizz Swimbaits "Rat" is likely the better choice. Its realistic design and specific features cater well to those summer evenings when fish are looking for surface prey.

  • On the other hand, if you value versatility and are interested in a unique design for year-round fishing, the FREEK FILES - SUBJECT:13 might be worth the investment, despite its higher price.

Ultimately, your choice should depend on your fishing goals, the specific conditions you'll encounter, and whether you prefer a realistic imitation versus a distinctive, creative design.

Side-by-side specs

Spec
Pizz Swimbaits "Rat"
Pizz Swimbaits "Rat"
Pizz Swimbaits
TypeTopwater BaitsTopwater Baits
MakerPizz SwimbaitsFreek Baits Custom Fishing Lures
Price$200$249
Weight3.5 oz (99 g)N/A
Length5.5 in (140 mm)N/A
Sink Ratefloatingfloating
Target Speciesbassbass
Techniquescasting, topwatercasting, topwater
Water Columnsurfacesurface
Running Depth0 ft0-1 ft
Actionsurface swimmingwake
Conditionslow light, open water, vegetationlow light, clear water, open water
Best SeasonSummerSummer
ExperienceProExpert
ColorsNatural, Gray, Black, Red, Green, YellowZombie, Pink, White, Red, Black
When to UseUse this bait as a surface presentation around calm to lightly broken water when fish are looking up. It is designed to imitate a rat swimming across the top, so steady retrieves and pauses can help trigger strikes from bass in low-light or cover-oriented situations.This is a wake bait designed to be retrieved just under or along the surface so it leaves a visible wake and pushes water. It’s best for slow to moderate retrieves around shallow cover, especially when fish are willing to track a larger profile bait. The oversized, custom look suggests it’s aimed at drawing reaction strikes from bigger bass.

Pros & Cons

Pizz Swimbaits "Rat"
Pros
  • Floating topwater swimbait profile
  • Rat imitation can draw aggressive surface strikes
  • Large size and weight for long casts
Cons
  • Very expensive
  • Specialized presentation, not a general-purpose lure
FREEK FILES - SUBJECT:13 - Zombie Lab Rat Wake Bait
Pros
  • Unique hand-painted custom profile
  • Surface wake presentation can trigger reaction bites
  • Large, high-visibility target
Cons
  • Likely expensive and collector-oriented
  • May be too specialized for everyday fishing
  • Surface presentation can be less effective in heavy chop

Compare your own lures

Pick any two lures and get an AI-powered breakdown — specs, pros & cons, and a verdict tailored to your question.

Start a new comparison